google.com, pub-7870541769880094, DIRECT, f08c47fec0942fa0

An IPS officer insists on first class qualifications; the university says ‘no’


The applicant made a representation to the University to cancel his marks as he failed to obtain the first division due to a shortfall of 0.09% of the total marks. | Photo Credit: FILE PHOTO

The Madras High Court on Tuesday adjourned for a week an appeal filed by the University of Madras against a single judge’s order to remove the 59.91% marks obtained by Indian Police Service (IPS) officer Pa Moorthy from 60% for consideration. that he passed his Masters in Law (ML) degree in the first class and not the second.

The First Division Bench of Acting Chief Justice D. Krishnakumar and Justice M. Jothiraman adjourned the hearing as the appeal could not be taken up on Tuesday due to lack of time. Another Division Bench of Justices R. Mahadevan (now a Supreme Court judge) and Mohammed Shaffiq had already reserved the judgment of the single judge on February 8 this year.

In 2022 Pa Moorthy, who is now serving as Deputy Inspector General of Police (Tirunelveli Range), had filed a petition in the Supreme Court claiming that he was pursuing his ML course (private course) at Madras University in the academic year 2018-19. . He told the court that he was able to complete these courses even though he had very little time to study.

Having failed to obtain a first class due to a deficiency of 0.09% of the total marks, the applicant made a presentation to the University to finalize his marks. This request was not considered and therefore, he went to the court and asked to cancel the communication with the Controller of Examinations on February 3, 2022 and therefore he issued an order to give him 60% marks.

When the writ petition was listed before Justice Abdul Quddhose on July 8, 2022, the judge took note of a 2017 order passed by another Supreme Court judge in a case involving similar facts. In that case, one judge had issued an order to remove 59.96% of the marks obtained by the law student to reach 60% so that the concerned student can be considered as having obtained first class.

Agreeing with the opinion taken by one judge in that case, Justice Quddhose said that the same benefit should be given to Mr. Moorthy too as he pursued legal studies although he was busy as an IPS officer and scored 59.91% marks only 0.09% short of the required first class degree.

“Therefore, the aggregate marks of the applicant in the ML degree course (private course) of the University of Madras is reduced to 60% instead of 59.91% obtained by him in the examinations and this writ petition is allowed,” ordered Judge Quddhose.

Dismissing the order by way of a writ petition, the University and its Controller of Examinations argued that the rules and regulations of the university do not empower the university authorities to cancel the marks obtained by the students and therefore, the single judge erred in passing. such an order.



Source link

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top